
NOTE: I’m judging these episodes as a Gleek, not as a critic.
CRITERIAS:
Episode Rating (rating for the episode as a whole)- */5
Song Choices (the way songs are chosen for each episode)- */5
Entertainment (how amusing,funny, or entertaining was the episode) - */5
Emotional Moments (how the dramatic elements were executed)- */5
Additional Comments-

PART I- Road to Sectionals
1- Pilot

Episode Rating- 3/5
Song Choices- 4/5
Entertainment- 3/5
Emotional Moments - 2/5
Additional Comments-
Does a great job of introducing the characters, and the ending song number (Don’t Stop Believin’) definitely solidifies, not just the the theme of the episode, but the series as the whole. You can already consider it as the show’s theme song.
2- Showmance

Episode Rating- 5/5
Song Choices- 5/5
Entertainment- 5/5
Emotional Moments - 3/5
Additional Comments-
This was my favorite Glee episode for a while, until “Vitamin D”, “Sectionals” and some of the Back 9 episodes came along. “Gold Digger”, “Take A Bow” and “Push It” were great, and the characters were shown to be slowly getting fleshed out.
3- Acafellas

Episode Rating- 3/5
Song Choices- 2/5
Entertainment- 3.5/5
Emotional Moments - 3/5
Additional Comments-
I wasn’t a big fan of the song choices. “I Wanna Sex You Up” was a good number though. The Josh Groban bit was also a nice touch.
4- Preggers

Episode Rating- 4/5
Song Choices- 2.5/5
Entertainment- 3.5/5
Emotional Moments - 4/5
Additional Comments-
This Glee episode ,remains to this day, to claim the title as to have the least number of songs featured in the episode. But still, I’m not bothered. The Kurt and Burt bits were pretty emotionally well-executed (those bits of theirs are usually the most heart-wrenching moments of the series). But the scene were Finn cries was pretty emotional as well, and the only song covered in the episode (Taking Chances) was used pretty well in the ending senes. It described the episode as a whole perfectly, with its guitar-heavy music overlying the scenes with the scenes of ambigiousity and boldness. But the dance in the beginning…was that really necessary? Very hard to watch, even though there were no violence involved. But the whole football team dancing to the Single Ladies was pretty funny.
5- The Rhodes Not Taken

Episode Rating- 4/5
Song Choices- 4/5
Entertainment-4.5/5
Emotional Moments- 3/5
Additional Comments-
Basically the direct sequel to “Pilot”. The two are basically the same. But still…good episode.
6- Vitamin D

Episode Rating- 4/5
Song Choices- 5/5
Entertainment- 4/5
Emotional Moments - 4/5
Additional Comments-
Again, I must remind you guys that I’m judging these episodes as a Gleek, not as a critic. I love this episode, with the whole boys vs girls plot, the Will/Emma/Terri triangle, and the songs. Oh man…the songs. AMAZING mash-ups.
7- Throwdown

Episode Rating- 4/5
Song Choices- 4/5
Entertainment- 5/5
Emotional Moments - 3/5
Additional Comments-
The Will vs Sue plot was freakin EPIC. Plus, the “Keep Holding On” song number at the end was a bit chilling. But I have to complain, that after just seven episodes, the glee club suddenly becomes incredibly close? Really?! The series really has problem with this issue. One episode, they’re all close, and then the next episode, they’re still split between the cool kids vs the geeks.
8- Mash-Up

Episode Rating- 3/5
Song Choices- 2.5/5
Entertainment- 4/5
Emotional Moments - 4/5
Additional Comments-
The episode dosen’t hold out a promise of having a mash-up song involved, which was a disappointment for me, considering how well they do on making mash-ups. But of course, that dosen’t agree with the overall message of the episode, regarding mash-ups. Emma’s “I Want to Dance All Night” was delightful, and a person like her was PERFECT to sing such a song. The slushie plot was also quite entertaining, and the part where Kurt suicide-slushies himself was HILARIOUS. But the episode does a good job of feeling sorry for both Emma and Will, especially with how they feel on Emma’s engagement.
9- Wheels

Episode Rating- 3.5/5
Song Choices- 4/5
Entertainment- 2/5
Emotional Moments - 3.5/5
Additional Comments-
This was a sadder Glee episode than usual (well, until “Dream On” came along, which can be considered as a direct sequel of this episode). Artie’s “Dancing with Myself” was sad, Kurt’s situation with his dad was heart-wrenchin as usual, and blah blah blah.
10- Ballad

Episode Rating- 5/5
Song Choices- 5/5
Entertainment- 5/5
Emotional Moments - 5/5
Additional Comments-
Back when I first watched it, I didn’t think this was a perfect Glee episode, but looking back…man, there was so many things that I missed. First of all, the episode was AWESOME. The plots were divided into two: the humorous one with Will and Rachel, and the dramatic one with Finn and Quinn. Will and Rachel’s plot was really well-done, and I chuckled a few times. In the Finn and Quinn plot though…let’s say things got dusty in the room. Cory Monteith and Dianna Argon really showed off their acting chops in the episode. FANTASTIC episode.
11- Hairography

Episode Rating- 1.5/5
Song Choices- 2/5
Entertainment-2.5/5
Emotional Moments - 3/5
Additional Comments-
I didn’t remember much from this episode, which pretty much brings up my point of this being one of my least favorite Glee episodes. Also, I actually like the “True Colors” number, unlike majority of the people.
12- Mattress

Episode Rating- 3.5/5
Song Choices- 3.5/5
Entertainment-3/5
Emotional Moments - 4/5
Additional Comments:
One of the things that I don’t like about Glee is that there’s no build up towards the main event (in this case, Sectionals) AT ALL. This episode showed no signs that the next episode after would be the big one. But pushing that aside, I liked this episode. “Smile (Lily Allen Version)” and “Jump” were truly awesome numbers. But the Will and Terri plot in the episode was INTENSE. It was so freakin uncomfortable to be watching that scene, as if you were actually in the same room with them. And the ending with the yearbook photo and “Smile (Charlie Chaplin Version)” playing on the background? Sad :( .
13- Sectionals

Episode Rating- 5/5
Song Choices- 5/5
Entertainment- 5/5
Emotional Moments - 5/5
Additional Comments- one of the best Glee episodes EVER. The emotional scenes (Finn going apeshit) are great, the humor and satire is hilarious, and everything seems to pay off here. REALLY LOVED THIS EPISODE.

Part II- Road to Regionals
14- Hell-O

Episode Rating- 5/5
Song Choices- 5/5
Entertainment-5/5
Emotional Moments- 5/5
Additional Comments-
Great comeback for Glee, since its three month hiatus.
15- The Power of Madonna

Episode Rating- 5/5
Song Choices- 5/5
Entertainment- 4/5
Emotional Execution- 4/5
Additional Comments-
As you can see from the rating, this is one of my most favorite Glee episodes…EVER. At first, before watching the episode, I was a bit hesitant to watch it, because, well….it’s Madonna, but after watching the episode numerous times, I suddenly gained a better appreciation for her. I LOVE “Borderline/Open Your Heart”, “Like A Virgin”…well, I pretty much LOVE almost every song in the episode.The sex-themed plot was also well-executed, though I will not believe that in real life, a guy will be horrified of losing their virginity to some hot girl.
16- Home

Episode Rating- 1.5/5
Song Choices- 1.5/5
Entertainment- 1/5
Emotional Moments- 4/5
Additional Comments-
This is pretty much my least favorite Glee episode, aside from “Hairography”. I know this was meant to be an emotional episode, but…I didn’t get it.
17- Bad Reputation

Episode Rating- 4.5/5
Song Choices- 4/5
Entertainment- 5/5
Emotional Moments- 5/5
Additional Comments-
Great episode. The whole Glist and bad reputation stuff involving Will and Sue was HILARIOUS. Not only was this a great and funny episode, but this was the first episode of Glee (I’m not counting on “Wheels”) to feature Sue as the protagonist, and Will to be somewhat the antagonist, and I love that. Also, the scenes with Sue and her sister? AMAZING. Heart-warming yet sad at the same time. Also, this may be the most fun Glee episode of the entire season. It dosen’t really too much on plot, and it’s more heavy on the entertainment of the viewers, which works.
18- Laryngitis

Episode Rating- 4/5
Song Choices- 3/5
Entertainment- 3/5
Emotional Moments- 4/5
Additional Comments-
I thought the plot with Rachel losing her voice due to singing Miley Cyrus’ song was really entertaining. But the scenes at the end involving Finn’s disabled friend….sad.
19- Dream On

Episode Rating- 4/5
Song Choices- 3.5/5
Entertainment- 2/5
Emotional Moments- 4/5
Additional Comments-
I’m glad that they featured Artie in the episode, because in the series, he’s the most unfortunate character out of all, and it’s good for the writers to address his condition more. Also, the dream theme in the episode was good, and really addressed dreams in a realistic tone.
PS: Barney Stinson in Glee? Legen…wait for it…dary!
20- Theatricality

Episode Rating- 5/5
Song Choices- 4.5/5
Entertainment- 4/5
Emotional Moments- 5/5
Additional Comments-
This episode (I think) wraps up the Finn and Kurt storyline, and it does it in an awesome way. All their scenes were intense, and the school bullying scenes were just hard to watch (because it was too effin cruel). The storyline with Rachel and Shelby was also REALLY great, and I’m glad the writers aren’t taking the usual cliche Rachel-joins-Vocal-Adrenaline-and-Shelby-is-just-evil storyline. I felt pity and rousing emotion towards every character in the episode, particulary Kurt and Rachel. Also, this episode features Lady Gaga and Bad Romance, which is an automatic A+ in my book.
21- Funk

Episode Rating- 3/5
Song Choices- 3/5
Entertainment- 3/5
Emotional Moments- 3/5
Additional Comments-
I liked the episode. It was fun, it was funky (no pun intended), and it was a great prelude to Regionals. The scene in the parking lot with Rachel and Vocal Adrenaline was just cruel, but I loved the aftermath and the song number that resulted from it (Give Up the Funk). What I loved about the recent episodes (this and “Theatricality”) was that I finally felt that the glee club members were genuinely close, unlike the past episodes where the creators tried to force the relationship into our faces.
22- Journey

Episode Rating- 5/5
Song Choices- 5/5
Entertainment- 5/5
Emotional Moments- 5/5
Additional Comments-
Before I watched this season finale episode, I already formulated the entire outcome in mind. New Directions wins or they lose. If they do lose, then the competition makes some sort of loophole or maybe there’s a mistake, and they end up winning first place anyway. Well duh, the show has already been renewed for not just a second, but a third season, so it’s perfectly sensible for me to come up with such a theory. Turns out that most of my predictions came true…except for the the fact that it was Sue herself who saved glee club. The scenes with Sue supporting the club were so heart-warming, that my heart almost melted enough to the point of making a fruit shake out of the remains. And the scenes with the club expressing sadness….I felt the same way too. I would have never felt it if we were still in the early episodes, but I’ve (as well as millions of viewers) have followed these characters for a year now. Of course it’s natural that I feel for what happens to them. All the emotional scenes were amazingly done, and the song numbers….really outmatched “Sectionals” (the episode, for me, was contradictory to the events that were held in this episode. Sectionals has the happy outcome, Journey…well, it dosen’t go the same route as the mentioned episode). I applaud the creators for coinciding the Bohemian Rhapsody number along with Quinn’s birth scene. PURE GENIUS.
This is the best way to end the season. And I mean, THE BEST WAY POSSIBLE. WHAT A FANTASTIC, FANTASIC SEASON FINALE.